The chancellor, George Osborne, has executed an audacious and politically significant U-turn by announcing the introduction of a cap on payday loans.
Osborne said the cap on the overall cost of credit was the next logical step as the coalition sought to regulate what had been a wholly unregulated market.
Labour said Monday's announcement was an admission by Osborne that he had got it wrong for years, and was once again being forced to respond to Labour's cost-of-living agenda.
The government has been resisting a cap on the much-reviled payday loans industry for years, saying the measure was not necessary or should wait for further investigations into the functioning of the industry.
Only last month the regulator the Financial Conduct Authority said there was no need for a cap and the issue had been referred to the Competition Commission for further discussion.
The timing of the announcement led observers to conclude that politics as much as policy had driven the decision, which comes only days before the autumn statement.
Until Monday's announcement, both the government and the FCA had been resisting the move despite strong pressure from Labour and individual Tory MPs eager for their party to be doing more to be seen on the side of hard-working people.
Senior Treasury officials last week met leading figures from the American community credit industry and the Federal Reserve. But the impetus appears to have been partly political and partly the product of conversations with the FCA.
Osborne said he was not just introducing a crude cap on interest rates but a cap on the overall cost of credit. He also announced that the banking bill would impose a duty on the new regulator to impose a cap.
He praised the Labour MP Stella Creasy for campaigning on the issue for so long, but refused to accept that her party deserved any credit. Osborne denied that the effective price restrictions were in breach of overall Conservative free market philosophy.
The move is likely to be seen as a sign that the party recognises that it needs to respond to Labour's continuing poll lead and the need to do more to help the low paid.
He said: "The Conservative philosophy is that you want markets that work for people, and people who believe in the free market, like myself, want that free market properly regulated."
He said payday lending was highly unregulated and "in fixing the banks it was necessary to fix all parts of the banking and financial system".
He added: "We have always believed in properly regulated but free markets where there is competition and consumer protection."The chancellor said he had been in discussion with the regulator and it became clear that parliament could set the duty on the regulator to have a cap.
"It is not just a cap on the rate of interest; [it is] the arrangement fees, the penalty fees if you fail to pay back, the rollover and restricting the use of continuous payment authority. When you look another countries and some US states there is increasing evidence that caps work. "Ultimately parliament and governments have got to lead.
We believe in regulated markets that work for working people." Citing the work of Adam Smith and John Locke, he said: "The idea that this is inconsistent with free market or Conservative philosophy is nonsense."
He rejected the idea that the coalition was following Labour, saying: "Labour was in office for 13 years. They were in the Treasury for all those years. They did absolutely nothing.
"I am happy to pay tribute to some individual MPs like Stella Creasy and Robin Walker, who have campaigned on this issue but the idea that the Labour leadership who were running this country for 13 years and did nothing in this space took a lead is frankly fanciful," Creasy, who was promoted to shadow business minister in the last opposition reshuffle, accused Osborne of following where Labour led.
She said: "Just two months ago this government criticised Ed Miliband for wanting to reform broken markets, and now today we see them following Labour's lead on the need to act against legal loan-sharking.
"Whether in parliament or out on Britain's streets in the Sharkstoppers campaign, we have been making the case that capping is a tried and tested method used in many other countries to tackle the problems caused by payday lenders.
"For too long David Cameron has ignored our pleas to act and it is cash-strapped consumers caught in the spiral of debt these companies generate who have paid a heavy price as a result.
"Labour is committed to caps on the total cost of credit and we know there's still more to do to address the damage this toxic industry has done to the lives of millions.
"We want a levy on these companies to expand the funds available to credit unions so they can serve more people, powers for councils to limit the growth of these companies on our high streets and a ban on advertising to children of these products.
"That the government is today admitting it got it wrong in opposing these measures and is still playing catchup on how to combat these problems shows it is Labour who have the ideas and determination to tackle Britain's cost-of-living crisis."
Osborne's change of heart came the day before peers were due to vote on an amendment hat would have set a maximum loan for pay day lenders.
The amendment, sponsored by the Liberal Democrat backbencher Lord Sharkey, would allow a maximum loan of £300, set a cap on charges of a maximum 10% of the loan value and prevent people from having two or more loans at the same time.
It would also have allowed a loan to run for no more than 31 days, with a 60-day extension, and require a 24-hour gap between loans.
Although the government has not adopted the specifics of the amendment – the cap will be decided by the FCA – Sharkey said: "Uncapped payday loans get people into real trouble so I am delighted George Osborne has acted in response to my amendment."
The head of Citizens Advice, Gillian Guy, said: "This is a cap on the exploitation of people struggling with the rising cost of living. Payday lenders have failed to stick to their own promises to treat customers fairly.The government's plan to cap the cost of loans only goes to show how out of control the industry is."
Russell Hamblin-Boone, the chief executive of the Consumer Finance Association, which represents the major short-term lenders operating in the UK, said: "We are surprised by the government's announcement as we already have voluntary caps on the number of times a loan can be extended and on fees and interest for people in financial difficulty.
"If the objective of the proposed cap is to drive out rogue lenders the Australian experience has had some success, however it has not reduced household debt or the need for credit. Instead there has been an increase in the number of people who turn to the growing illegal lending market, which the Australian regulator has admitted is a problem."
theguardian.com
Osborne said the cap on the overall cost of credit was the next logical step as the coalition sought to regulate what had been a wholly unregulated market.
Labour said Monday's announcement was an admission by Osborne that he had got it wrong for years, and was once again being forced to respond to Labour's cost-of-living agenda.
The government has been resisting a cap on the much-reviled payday loans industry for years, saying the measure was not necessary or should wait for further investigations into the functioning of the industry.
Only last month the regulator the Financial Conduct Authority said there was no need for a cap and the issue had been referred to the Competition Commission for further discussion.
The timing of the announcement led observers to conclude that politics as much as policy had driven the decision, which comes only days before the autumn statement.
Until Monday's announcement, both the government and the FCA had been resisting the move despite strong pressure from Labour and individual Tory MPs eager for their party to be doing more to be seen on the side of hard-working people.
Senior Treasury officials last week met leading figures from the American community credit industry and the Federal Reserve. But the impetus appears to have been partly political and partly the product of conversations with the FCA.
Osborne said he was not just introducing a crude cap on interest rates but a cap on the overall cost of credit. He also announced that the banking bill would impose a duty on the new regulator to impose a cap.
He praised the Labour MP Stella Creasy for campaigning on the issue for so long, but refused to accept that her party deserved any credit. Osborne denied that the effective price restrictions were in breach of overall Conservative free market philosophy.
The move is likely to be seen as a sign that the party recognises that it needs to respond to Labour's continuing poll lead and the need to do more to help the low paid.
He said: "The Conservative philosophy is that you want markets that work for people, and people who believe in the free market, like myself, want that free market properly regulated."
He said payday lending was highly unregulated and "in fixing the banks it was necessary to fix all parts of the banking and financial system".
He added: "We have always believed in properly regulated but free markets where there is competition and consumer protection."The chancellor said he had been in discussion with the regulator and it became clear that parliament could set the duty on the regulator to have a cap.
"It is not just a cap on the rate of interest; [it is] the arrangement fees, the penalty fees if you fail to pay back, the rollover and restricting the use of continuous payment authority. When you look another countries and some US states there is increasing evidence that caps work. "Ultimately parliament and governments have got to lead.
We believe in regulated markets that work for working people." Citing the work of Adam Smith and John Locke, he said: "The idea that this is inconsistent with free market or Conservative philosophy is nonsense."
He rejected the idea that the coalition was following Labour, saying: "Labour was in office for 13 years. They were in the Treasury for all those years. They did absolutely nothing.
"I am happy to pay tribute to some individual MPs like Stella Creasy and Robin Walker, who have campaigned on this issue but the idea that the Labour leadership who were running this country for 13 years and did nothing in this space took a lead is frankly fanciful," Creasy, who was promoted to shadow business minister in the last opposition reshuffle, accused Osborne of following where Labour led.
She said: "Just two months ago this government criticised Ed Miliband for wanting to reform broken markets, and now today we see them following Labour's lead on the need to act against legal loan-sharking.
"Whether in parliament or out on Britain's streets in the Sharkstoppers campaign, we have been making the case that capping is a tried and tested method used in many other countries to tackle the problems caused by payday lenders.
"For too long David Cameron has ignored our pleas to act and it is cash-strapped consumers caught in the spiral of debt these companies generate who have paid a heavy price as a result.
"Labour is committed to caps on the total cost of credit and we know there's still more to do to address the damage this toxic industry has done to the lives of millions.
"We want a levy on these companies to expand the funds available to credit unions so they can serve more people, powers for councils to limit the growth of these companies on our high streets and a ban on advertising to children of these products.
"That the government is today admitting it got it wrong in opposing these measures and is still playing catchup on how to combat these problems shows it is Labour who have the ideas and determination to tackle Britain's cost-of-living crisis."
Osborne's change of heart came the day before peers were due to vote on an amendment hat would have set a maximum loan for pay day lenders.
The amendment, sponsored by the Liberal Democrat backbencher Lord Sharkey, would allow a maximum loan of £300, set a cap on charges of a maximum 10% of the loan value and prevent people from having two or more loans at the same time.
It would also have allowed a loan to run for no more than 31 days, with a 60-day extension, and require a 24-hour gap between loans.
Although the government has not adopted the specifics of the amendment – the cap will be decided by the FCA – Sharkey said: "Uncapped payday loans get people into real trouble so I am delighted George Osborne has acted in response to my amendment."
The head of Citizens Advice, Gillian Guy, said: "This is a cap on the exploitation of people struggling with the rising cost of living. Payday lenders have failed to stick to their own promises to treat customers fairly.The government's plan to cap the cost of loans only goes to show how out of control the industry is."
Russell Hamblin-Boone, the chief executive of the Consumer Finance Association, which represents the major short-term lenders operating in the UK, said: "We are surprised by the government's announcement as we already have voluntary caps on the number of times a loan can be extended and on fees and interest for people in financial difficulty.
"If the objective of the proposed cap is to drive out rogue lenders the Australian experience has had some success, however it has not reduced household debt or the need for credit. Instead there has been an increase in the number of people who turn to the growing illegal lending market, which the Australian regulator has admitted is a problem."
theguardian.com
No comments:
Post a Comment